Rodale Book of Composting: Best for Enthusiasts

At a glance: The Rodale Book of Composting is overwhelming and under-illustrated for new composters, but the breadth and depth of information makes it the perfect choice for the enthusiast.

I’ve had and used the Rodale Book of Composting for years, but I’ve held off reviewing it until now because I had an older edition (1992). Despite that, I’ve always found it to be an excellent resource, containing plenty of information that I haven’t seen in any other (affordable!) composting book, so let’s see how the newest version stacks up against other options. 

What’s to like?

If you’re fascinated in everything to do with composting, this book is for you. You’ll find in-depth coverage of everything from the history and science of compost to different materials and multiple composting methods.

I particularly like how it suggests methods you will be hard pressed to discover elsewhere, often exploring them in depth. For example, it’s the only resource I’ve seen which mentions stair stepped bins, a system of compost structures that use gravity to make turning earlier. 

It’s also perfect for the composter or medium scale organic farmer/market gardener who wants to really deepen their skill and knowledge. Here you can really dive into the differences between types of manure, or use information on other compost materials to fine tune your composting process. 

What’s not to like?

Quite simply, this book is not ideal for the absolute beginner, or for someone just looking for a simple guide to composting.

In fact, you have to get to chapter 8 (and plough past dozens of pages on materials) before you get a look at methods, and even then there’s no simple guide to starting, layering and maintaining a compost bin or pile. I’d also like to see more plans for creating compost systems, and for illustrations that go beyond simple black and white line drawings to make it more accessible for less experienced composters.

The same goes for the new composters interested in vermicomposting. The chapter on worms contains interesting tips for utilising earthworms in composting systems, but the key information on home setups is tucked deeper into the chapter, requiring a bit of patience to uncover.

Verdict

I love this book, but that doesn’t mean it’s right for everyone. 

In fact, the very information that makes it valuable for the enthusiast makes it overwhelming for the beginner. A new composter, for example, doesn’t need to understand the intricacies of dozens of different compost materials, or need advice on choosing a tractor.

You could still use the information to get started, but a better choice is Composting for a New Generation, which is very much focussed on getting you started, and also makes life easy by providing plenty of well-illustrated plans. 

If you’re interested in vermicomposting, check out Worms Ate My Garbage as the Rodale Book of Composting’s section on vermicomposting seems to be based on this book anyway, albeit in less detail. 

That said, if you’re ready to dive deep and truly explore the art and science of composting, The Rodale Book of Composting remains a unique and invaluable resource.